How to Help Your Parents Choose a Medicare Plan

Helping Parents Choose a Medicare Plan
by James

Read time: 8 min

Helping Parents Choose a Medicare Plan

If you've found yourself Googling this, you're probably the one in your family who ends up handling things, and Medicare has landed on your plate. Whether your parent is approaching 65 or has been on a plan for years and just seems overwhelmed by it, helping them choose the right coverage for their needs is one of the more meaningful (and confusing) things you can do for them.

The tricky part is that you're not the one enrolling. You're doing the research, comparing the options, and often making the recommendation, but your parent still has to be the one who authorizes it. This guide walks through how to do that well: what to gather, how to get permission to act on their behalf, and how to actually compare plans without getting lost in the process.

Compare Medicare Plans With Healthpilot

Quick reference for helping a parent choose Medicare: what to gather, how to get permission, key enrollment periods, and scam red flags to watch for.

Can You Choose a Medicare Plan for Your Parents?

Not entirely on your own, and that's a good thing. Medicare plans are tied to your parent's Social Security number and personal health information, so any enrollment, plan change, or account access ultimately requires their authorization. What you can do is everything short of that: research options, compare costs, call doctors' offices to confirm networks, and walk your parent through the final decision so they're choosing with full information instead of guessing.

If your parent has significant cognitive decline or you hold power of attorney, your role may extend further. That's a legal question specific to your family's situation, so it's worth confirming with an elder law attorney or your parent's estate planning documents rather than assuming.

Getting Permission to Speak with Medicare on Your Parent's Behalf

If you want to call Medicare directly, or have a plan's customer service team discuss your parent's coverage with you, your parent needs to authorize that first. Medicare won't discuss personal health or coverage information with anyone who isn't on file as an authorized contact, including you.

What to Gather Before You Start Comparing Plans

Before you open a single plan comparison tool, get these basics from your parent:

  • Current doctors and specialists: names and locations, especially any specialists they see regularly
  • Current medications: names, dosages, and how often they're filled
  • Health conditions: chronic conditions like diabetes or COPD can affect which plan type makes sense
  • Budget comfort: what they're currently paying and what they can reasonably afford if costs change
  • Travel habits: snowbirds who split time between states need different coverage than someone who stays local
  • ZIP code: plan availability and pricing are hyper-local, so this determines what even shows up as an option

Having this list in hand before you start comparing plans will save you from having to backtrack later.

Authorization to Disclose Personal Health Information

This is the standard form for giving you (or anyone else) permission to talk to Medicare on your parent's behalf. Your parent can set this up by calling 1-800-MEDICARE or through their MyMedicare.gov account, and it can be limited to certain topics or time periods if they'd prefer not to give blanket access.

Healthcare Proxy or Power of Attorney

If your parent has designated you as a healthcare proxy or financial power of attorney, that may also allow you to act on their behalf, but the scope of what that covers, and what documentation Medicare or a given plan will accept, depends on how the document is written and where your parent lives. If this applies to your family, it's worth having your parent's attorney confirm what it does and doesn't authorize specifically with respect to Medicare before you rely on it.

💡 Worth knowing: Even with proper authorization, it's worth having your parent nearby (or looped in by phone) for major calls. Plans and Medicare representatives sometimes may want to confirm the beneficiary's consent directly, depending on the situation and the organization’s policies.

Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage vs. Medigap: Which Fits Your Parent?

This is usually the biggest decision, and it comes down to your parent's health needs more than anything else.

Original Medicare

Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) is accepted by any provider nationwide that takes Medicare, with no networks or referrals required. On its own, though, it doesn't cap out-of-pocket costs — your parent pays 20% coinsurance on most services indefinitely, which is where Medigap often comes in.

Medigap

Medigap is supplemental coverage that pairs with Original Medicare to help fill in the gaps, including things like coinsurance, copays, and deductibles that Original Medicare alone doesn't cover. For a parent who sees several specialists, travels often, or simply wants the most predictable monthly costs, Medigap paired with Original Medicare tends to be the most worry-free combination. The tradeoff is typically a higher combined monthly premium and no built-in extras like dental or vision.

⚠️ Important: Medigap plans use medical underwriting outside of specific guaranteed-issue windows, and the rules around when guaranteed issue applies vary by state. If your parent is considering Medigap outside their initial enrollment window, timing and state rules both matter and are worth confirming before applying.

Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage plans typically bundle medical, drug, and often additional benefit coverage into one plan, frequently with a lower premium. The tradeoff is a defined provider network and, in many cases, referral requirements for specialists — both worth checking carefully if your parent has established relationships with specific doctors.

If your parent mostly sees one primary care doctor, doesn't travel much, and wants to keep costs low and predictable, Medicare Advantage is often the simpler fit. If they see multiple specialists, travel frequently, or strongly prefer provider flexibility and cost predictability, Original Medicare paired with Medigap may serve them better.

How to Compare Plans

Medicare's Plan Finder tool at medicare.gov lets you search by ZIP code and filter by plan type, and it will show estimated costs based on the medications you enter. It's thorough, but it also means combing through a lot of plan documents and jargon to compare options.

Healthpilot's plan comparison tool pulls all of the above into a simpler side-by-side view, built specifically for this kind of decision. You enter your parent’s doctors, prescriptions, and how they typically use healthcare. Then, Healthpilot’s proprietary algorithm gives each available plan a Plan Fit Score based on that information. The score draws on objective plan data, including whether their doctors are in network, how their prescriptions are covered and what they’re likely to cost, estimated total yearly costs, premiums and out-of-pocket limits, CMS Star Ratings, and extra benefits. Instead of weighing all of those factors yourself, you can see at a glance which plans may fit your parent best and why. That’s especially useful if you’re doing this research on their behalf and want to move through it efficiently.

Compare Your Parent's Medicare Options

Checking Doctor Networks and Medication Coverage

This step matters more than almost anything else, and it's the one people most often skip or do carelessly.

Confirming Doctors Are In-Network

Plan directories are notorious for being out of date. Before assuming a doctor is in-network, call the doctor's office directly and ask if they currently accept the specific plan you're considering, not just "Medicare" broadly, since Medicare Advantage networks vary plan by plan. Alternatively, you can use Healthpilot’s comparison tool to see if a doctor is in-network for a specific plan.

Checking the Formulary

Every Medicare Advantage and Part D plan has a formulary, a list of covered drugs, organized into cost tiers. Enter your parent's exact medications, including dosage, into the plan's formulary tool before assuming coverage. A medication being "covered" doesn't always mean it's covered at the lowest tier, so check the tier level too, since that affects the actual out-of-pocket cost. Healthpilot will give you actual cost estimates for each drug when comparing plans.

Comparing the Real Costs (Not Just the Premium)

A low-premium plan isn't necessarily the cheapest option once you factor in the rest of the cost structure. Walk through each of these for any plan you're seriously considering:

  • Monthly premium: what your parent pays every month regardless of care used
  • Deductible: what they pay out of pocket before coverage kicks in
  • Copay or coinsurance: the cost per visit or service once the deductible is met
  • Out-of-pocket maximum (MOOP): the most your parent would pay in a year before the plan covers 100%

If your parent has ongoing health needs or several specialists, a slightly higher premium with a lower MOOP can end up being the cheaper option overall once you run the numbers.

Compare Total Expected Costs and Coverage With Healthpilot

Timing It Right: Enrollment Periods to Know

Initial Enrollment Period (IEP)

The Initial Enrollment Period applies if your parent is turning 65; it's a seven-month window centered on their birthday month. Missing it can mean lifelong late enrollment penalties, so this is worth calendaring early.

Annual Enrollment Period (AEP)

The Annual Enrollment Period applies if your parent already has Medicare and wants to make a change. AEP runs October 15 through December 7 each year, with new coverage starting January 1.

Special Enrollment Period (SEP)

A Special Enrollment Period (SEP) applies when certain events happen outside AEP — like your parent's plan leaving their area, losing other coverage, or moving. It opens a window to switch plans without waiting for AEP.

⚠️ Important: SEP eligibility windows and start dates vary depending on the specific qualifying event, so it's worth confirming your parent's exact window rather than assuming a standard timeline applies.

Reviewing the ANOC Letter Together Each Fall

Every September, Medicare Advantage and Part D plans send an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) letter outlining what's changing for the following year — premiums, covered drugs, network changes, and more. This is worth reviewing with your parent every single year, even if they've been happy with their plan, since a plan that worked well last year can look very different after changes take effect.

If your parent's ANOC shows a doctor leaving the network, a medication moving to a higher tier, or a meaningful premium increase, that's a strong signal to compare alternatives before AEP closes.

Protecting Your Parents from Medicare Scams

Medicare beneficiaries are frequent targets for scams, and your parent may not always recognize the warning signs. A few things worth flagging with them directly:

  • Medicare and Social Security will never call unsolicited asking for personal information or payment
  • No legitimate plan will pressure someone to enroll on the spot during a cold call
  • Anyone offering "free" medical equipment in exchange for a Medicare number should be treated as a red flag

For a fuller breakdown of common tactics and how to report them, see our guide to avoiding Medicare scams and fraud.

Free and Low-Cost Help: SHIP Counselors vs. Independent Brokers

You don't have to do all of this alone, and there are a few different types of help available depending on how hands-on you want to be.

SHIP Counseling

Every state has a free State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP), staffed by trained counselors who offer unbiased, one-on-one guidance with no sales agenda. This is a strong first stop if you want a second opinion without any pressure toward a specific plan.

Independent Brokers vs. Captive Agents

A captive agent represents one insurance carrier and can only sell that carrier's plans. An independent broker is licensed to sell plans from multiple carriers, which generally means a broader, more objective comparison. Both are paid on commission by the insurance carrier (not by you), but an independent broker's incentives are less tied to any single company's product. That being said, many independent brokers only represent a limited number of carriers. You will want to look for one with a broad range of carriers offered to best understand the plan options in your area.

Get Help From a Licensed Healthpilot Medicare Agent

You've done the research; now it's about walking your parent through the decision, not making it for them. Lay out two or three finalists, explain the trade-offs in plain terms, and let them ask questions before deciding.

If you'd rather have a licensed expert walk through the comparison with your parent directly, Healthpilot's agents can do that at no cost.

Talk to a Licensed Healthpilot Medicare Agent

Call (855) 922-5051

Helping Parents Choose a Medicare Plan: FAQs

  • Not without their login credentials or a formal authorization on file. If they want you to have ongoing access, they can add you as an authorized representative through their account settings or by contacting Medicare directly.

  • Both pull from similar underlying plan data, but Healthpilot's tool is built for a faster, simpler side-by-side comparison, with clear plan fit scores that show how well a plan will work for an individual’s unique needs. Healthpilot also has more reliable doctor network information. In a 2024 study by the CMS Innovation Center, Healthpilot was 7x more accurate at predicting the lowest-cost plan for an individual compared to Medicare’s Plan Finder.

  • At minimum, every fall when the ANOC arrives. Even a plan that's worked well can shift enough year to year that it's worth a quick comparison before AEP closes.

  • You can still do all of this research remotely — the Plan Finder and Healthpilot's tool both work by ZIP code, so you'll just need your parent's local ZIP code and their permission to act on their behalf by phone.

Continue Reading

We're Here to Help with Any Questions

  • Talk to an Agent

    Expert, non-commissioned Medicare advisors are available Mon–Fri: 8am–8pm CT · Sat–Sun: 9am–6 pm CT

    Call (855) 922-5051 TTY 711
  • Chat Online

    Our agents typically get back to you within two minutes.

  • Send Us an Email

    Share your questions with us in an email, and we'll get back to you with tailored advice.

    [email protected]